Friday, June 7, 2019

Hermeneutics, a slippery slope or well needed for lay education?

As an active pastoral leader for the last few years, every week you are for the most part utilizing this important tool for not only preaching but of course teaching.  Why I’ve been thinking about writing about this recently is in hearing people’s viewpoints on the sovereignty of Scripture and how should we actually begin looking at, studying God’s Living Word?  How I have come to understand this and essentially have come to teach it is history, context and truth.  I’m sure there’s umpteen number of articles out there challenging and debating how one should look at the Scriptures… but those three fingers: history, context and truth are the most basic and digestible for your congregations to consider.

Starting with history, that one is pretty basic. What is history but literally where the world was at a particular time and place and its outcome.  Of course, this could branch out into several subcategories that could become a lot more complex, but I think that keeping this concept simple and relative to those you are trying to teach is fairly important.  It’s fairly important because we are a people that have not only evolved in one fashion or another but have developed patterns of philosophy, arts and intellectual thought.  We can’t ignore our moments of failure or our moments of flourishing as a people of faith.  The Scriptures quite literally in themselves, we have to keep the lens of thinking through history unfettered by bias or agenda.

Keeping the lens of history clear has been the most challenging for us today thanks to the death work of politics layering its bias upon worldly culture and the culture of the church.  What is not progress for the post-modern church to understand and uphold the sovereignty of the Scriptures is incorporating a typological layer of personal political context to the actual history of a particular era of Christian writings. We have seen this rob and mangle the Scriptures’ efficacy to teach the power of Christ’s truth being mutuality, Agape Love, compassion, spiritual formation and selflessness.  A good example of this is thinking of the concept of slavery.  The American culture and for the most part, most of the known world has conscientiously fought and eradicated enslavement out of the tier of society.  Of course, we have still had problems today with sex trafficking, indenturement and related evils in areas of the world, but we, for the most part, do not accept slavery as a valid aspect of life as former cultures once did.  If anything, America has condemned this and does not say that the inerrant Word of God wants us to keep slavery for that is frankly absurd for us today.

The “punishing parent” image of the Old Testament God is another historical note for us to keep in consideration.  There are many a fundamentalist preacher out there that uses the legalistic viewpoints from the Old Testament to inadvertently weaken the power of Christ’s eternally freeing Grace.  During that time in the history of the Jewish culture, the Pharisees were perhaps being fundamentalist about this viewpoint of God claiming absolute obedience to the Law and YHWH’s consequences to our departure. They were a tribal, nomadic people.  They were a patriarchal culture, period.  Where we are today, not only in our realm of the world but as a post-modern people of faith…  The Gospel truth becomes clearer in one sense, when we think of mutuality.  What does this mean specifically? Jesus taught about acceptance as agape love, He never used the word, tolerance.  Tolerance is an Old Natured word… But we have subjected our own self-righteous political lens of agenda over and above the radical Gospel note of Jesus’ call to acceptance. 

Perhaps one of the most disturbing things I have heard to date was at a convocation claiming that we need to find new ways to make Christ’s Gospel “relevant” again for our pastoral leaders and congregations…  How can the radical timeless Gospel of Christ ever become irrelevant?!  That’s ridiculous.  Agape Love is one the eternal truths that shines ever brightly in many instances throughout the Scriptures, even in the Old Testament.  Would it be fair to say that manna in the wilderness was an act of agape love, grace for the Israelites?  As we know in the New Testament, St. Paul always challenged us to think about God’s work in, with and through us.  Some of these challenges were hard to hear:

“19Now we know that whatever the law says, it speaks to those who are under the law, so that every mouth may be silenced, and the whole world may be held accountable to God. 20For “no human being will be justified in his sight” by deeds prescribed by the law, for through the law comes the knowledge of sin. 21But now, apart from law, the righteousness of God has been disclosed, and is attested by the law and the prophets, 22the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe. For there is no distinction, 23since all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God; 24they are now justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, 25whom God put forward as a sacrifice of atonement by his blood, effective through faith.”  Romans 3:19-25

“We all fall short of the glory of God…” is the humble description of simul justus et peccator (we are simultaneously saint and sinner)!  I have come to teach this as we are both aspiring saint and wanton sinner…  The problem of the will has also truly become our problem today of interpreting the Scriptures as well.  How can willful creatures of God ever understand or have moments of covenantal, unconditional divinely based love for their neighbor yet alone reflect that enough through a mustard-seed of personal faith?  We can only have moments of this kind of love, this is very much a truth to our human condition.  Why would anyone think or challenge this Biblical truth to be irrelevant for us today?  The death work of politics as an added hermeneutic or lens to understanding the historic Jesus, the era of His ministry on earth and our post-modern agenda centered around the self has caused this.

In regard to mutuality as a Biblical truth revealed in the Scriptures, we have seen and experienced many areas of conflicted thoughts to what the sovereign Word genuinely says.  This is, as mentioned earlier, a problem with not keeping the lens of history clear and separate from our typological input and bias but keeping the context of the authors of the Scriptures clear as a lens as well.  I recently debated someone who challenged me in saying since I believe Jesus had women disciples and treated all people more or less, equally… that I was “revising” God’s truth for women to be submissive to men.  When I countered the conversation by saying that God is wanting us to be submissive and obedient to Him alone.  I was told that the Word is absolute, and everything is literal and to be followed…  So how then for example, would you teach the story of the Samaritan Woman then?  How would you teach the story of Lydia in the Book of Acts and so on and so forth?

The moment we align ourselves to eliminate studying God’s Word through the unfettered lens of history, context of the author and the Biblical truth of the Gospel; we’re going to be in trouble, period.  The Beatitudes of Christ are more or less the New commandments stemming from the Lord’s call to us to incorporate agape love as our New Natured self.  Agape love is an altruistic love that shows no judgment but compassion as well as it is profoundly inclusive of both saint and sinner…  Biblically sovereign throughout the Gospel is God’s call to us to turn our hearts’ will obediently to His.  This is truly what God continues to call us beyond the Scriptures to do is to submit to His will.  As His servant Paul tells us:

“6For while we were still weak, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. 7Indeed, rarely will anyone die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person someone might actually dare to die. 8But God proves his love for us in that while we still were sinners Christ died for us. 9Much more surely then, now that we have been justified by his blood, will we be saved through him from the wrath of God. 10For if while we were enemies, we were reconciled to God through the death of his Son, much more surely, having been reconciled, will we be saved by his life.”  Romans 5:6-10

“5For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we will certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his. 6We know that our old self was crucified with him so that the body of sin might be destroyed, and we might no longer be enslaved to sin. 7For whoever has died is freed from sin. 8But if we have died with Christ, we believe that we will also live with him. 9We know that Christ, being raised from the dead, will never die again; death no longer has dominion over him. 10The death he died, he died to sin, once for all; but the life he lives, he lives to God. 11So you also must consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus.”  Romans 6:5-11

These are two amazing passages from Paul’s letter to the Romans that not only take us through the reason why we are to be obedient to the call of Christ but how God is to continue working through our lives in the way we reap our New Nature lives. The genuine authority to God’s Word is the New life contained, exampled and previewed by Christ.  Christ never abdicated slavery yet alone endorsed an exclusive Gospel.  This is what we have done when we look through our own vertical lens to interpreting the Scriptures.  What the vertical means is a fundamentalist lens of God and us alone with considering the horizontal.  The horizontal as you can imagine one making is the shape of the cross.  With our arms and hands stretched outward thinking about the world, thinking about the gift of Christ; we are encompassing the world in our prayerful reach. What a beautiful thought!

Hermeneutics when faithfully and truthfully implemented in either exegesis for preaching or teaching/ leading Biblical study will adhere to the sovereign integrity of the Living Word.  We are to be stewards to the integrity of the Scriptures.  Just like being stewards of the environment, we are to be stewards to keeping the environment of Biblical study free from the death works of the ego, politics and despair.  I will close this article with two Scriptures, one used in the LBW’s Call to Confession and the other, a timeless truth:

“8If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. 9If we confess our sins, he who is faithful and just will forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.”  1 John 1:8-9

“7Remember your leaders, those who spoke the word of God to you; consider the outcome of their way of life, and imitate their faith. 8Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever. 9Do not be carried away by all kinds of strange teachings; for it is well for the heart to be strengthened by grace…”  Hebrews 13:7-9

Be a faithful steward of the Word, if not for yourself, for the little part of the world that you live in that truly needs it the most—

Reverend Nicole A.M. Collins


Tuesday, May 28, 2019

Grace Crumbs; chaplaincy to culture or freely responsible pastoring for Christ?

I’ve enjoyed an interesting journey back to Illinois as I work towards finding another call in ministry. During this time, I was able to venture into experience Evangelical “mega” church worship.  In a spirit of keeping this article an open critique and observation, I will not be naming the church visited in my article.  What first came to mind when I came to the first service is the idea and concept that there is no such thing {{really}} as a non-denominational church.  According to many a colleague conversation, all “non-denom’s” are more or less “quiet” Baptists. I did think of my brief finishing studies at TEDS occasionally attending the chapel there and wondering about the interlinking chain of non-stop praise music and prayer.

As a product of church planting, there’s something to be said about both speaking to creating worship in light of some “bells and smells,” as well as incorporating or fine-tuning existing rubrics of spiritual transition to enhance the theological and spiritual strength of a service.  Stepping into an oddly shaped or perhaps intentionally designed giant structure that both incorporated an almost iconic white steeple and Colonial front, alongside a factory sheet metal warehouse, made you think about where their priorities are set.  The inside of the structure is set up much like a mall with interconnecting rooms or hallways highlighting different ministries and meetings.  Their youth set up reminded me of stepping into a movie theatre box office.  Everything, in essence, spoke to the secular culture with an accent of speaking to what people should consider “doing” after their multifaceted Sunday experience panorama.

What I found myself questioning and reflecting a lot upon was if this set up of church was faithfully including the marks of the church in spiritual practice being Koinonia, Didache, Diakonia, Kerygma and Lietourgia.  This past Summer I wrote an extensive paper on Lutheran worship based upon my studies, experiments and appreciation of it.  Was this popular mega-church speaking faithfully enough to community, teaching, service, witnessing the Word and worship? What I experienced in both services was primarily a vertical sense of instilling, stirring up faith and some abstract moralistic principles but the horizontal, being our sharing in the world, seemed truncated. It was like thinking of the cross that had its sides only reaching so far.  Is this a reflection of appealing too much to culture?  The finely polished auditorium or amphitheater donned no cross yet alone was set up and ready to go for loud interlinking traditional and modern Christian hymns, rock songs and related. I’ve never been someone to “flick a lighter to Jesus” in any setting, (though I really do like K Love, in my car!) but I held back overly criticizing this to see how clear and solid their theology was.

Echoing that thought again, are some of these churches appealing too much to culture(?); had me think of Bonhoeffer and his quest to clarify discipleship as an obedience that can only really come from realizing costly Grace.  This Costly grace, the great pearl of Christ given to the heart of those who truly come to believe, receive, incorporate said Grace, Word of God and share it.  Much like the mega Lutheran church I went to in Las Vegas, I saw myself thinking of a giant Sundae with all things wonderfully put in place except for the Grace which seemed like little crumbs just cautiously sprinkled on top.  Why were these churches doing something like this? Both churches had million-dollar coffers regularly filled… Strong enough pastors to at least teach simple concepts very well but neither place would touch the full Monty call of Grace with a 10-foot pole.

There is a fine line to witnessing the Word of God as a faith-filled disciple in the 21st century.  The radical call of the Gospel of Christ to ‘Be-the-Attitude’ should be something that is timeless, inspiring and truly motivating to be as Luther’s favorite author James said: ‘Doers of the Word.’  When I think of my own discipleship journey to where I am now, I’ve never stopped learning and growing with God’s Word and what He needs my heart to realize as a pastor to His church.  The artist in me can and did appreciate the non-denom’s abstract art behind the worship stage.  The image captured both a sense of the cross as well as an arrow pointing straight up.  While we’re to be looking up to hear God’s Word speak to and commission our hearts to service, what are we seeing right next to us?  What are we to see beyond the auditorium and theater-like interlinking hallways? That aspect was not made clear for me.

Being a disciple is a very real, standing on solid ground reality. Bonhoeffer had this understanding most beautifully and profoundly realized in his own mission to help save the German church.  We can not truthfully “grow and go” upon moralistic abstractions to help us with the nitty gritty of response to the world as His disciples.  Costly Grace is neither to be considered a moralistic abstraction or be diluted to palatable nuggets of “comfort” for the disciple’s growth.  It is our hearts turning to God, knocking on God’s door and really asking, growing, seeking, believing in what the awesome Grace of God does: NEW LIFE.
New Life in a Chronos-bent 9 to 5 world encapsulates the problem in expression, wisdom and commissioning.  Worship is the fuel to gathering together as the Body in the world (but not to be of it).  We forget that last part all too easily during this time of transition in society, culture and context. Much like art, one needs to think of the elemental aspects of its design.  For me what has always been important to composing worship is its solid spiritual formation’s design alongside of course, good theology.  Music is the “sound” to burgeon our natural charismatic reflections to God.  You can’t just throw Advent hymnary off to the side for Christmas hymns, just because someone wants it that way... Well, partly because: Jesus isn’t supposed to be born yet! I thought about this in connection to when I went to this first service.  I thought to myself, ok, K-Love top 40 greatest hits…  As much as I liked that music, was it relevant to the expository sermon series the pastors were preaching upon? ‘Satisfied.’

The main theological nugget to take away from this first service was witnessing wisdom. They look to a snippet from St. Paul’s letter to the Colossians 4:2-6. They basically extrapolate four nuggets of discipline St. Paul seeks for the flock at Colossae to accept: Pray intentionally, communicate clearly, live wisely and speak graciously.  In regard to marketing the teaching element here, they made bookmarks that were handed out at the end of the service for those to reflect on the message more on their own. I’ve tried something similar with ‘Sermon Nuggets’ inserts in some bulletins during the church year. These are four solid statements but how do we take those “life-instructions” internally to change the disciple’s heart most concretely to God? These statements can be seen as the mirror of the Law but what about Gospel? This is probably the problem I find with expository preaching.  It is very mechanical and precise in exegeting a particular slice of the moment in Paul’s pastoral journey, but it stops short or is made to seem to stop short here and become purely instruction.

If this particular community was following any kind of lectionary perhaps reflecting upon this calendar years’ days of Easter, the monumental impact of the resurrection upon the disciples from that day forward would’ve spoken more towards agape love and metanoia.  The heart of the Gospel is the love of Christ being the conquering force against sin, death and evil.  If we lay claim daily in remembering our Baptism to this truth as His disciples, why aren’t we speaking more directly to it? This goes beyond my Lutheran shading here: Do we faithfully teach the process and progress of the heart turning to God as an aspect of aspiring to incorporate, understand agape love?  I’ll close this article by sharing a wonderful dream I had thinking of talking to Him and asking Him how I was doing as His disciple.  He said: “Nicole, my daughter, I know the artist in you is trying to see me as the Jesus from Franco Zefferelli’s movie with a touch of St. Catherine of Sienna’s monastery painting of my human self… but think of me as the light in the world, the light in your very heart and my face will show within many you come to minister to.”

That was a powerful dream for me and was recent.  I may have been trying to ask from my heart what God wants me to do next… but what I saw was just His mouth, and I thought prayerfully of His Word in every day that past week. This is what “church” should be doing for us every day after the Sunday time of gathering. God’s Word becomes ubiquitous to being challenged to thrive or flourish within the problem of the human condition.  God’s purpose and instruction needs to be realized through costly grace.  We must be careful of offering or accepting the crumbs.

Rev. Nicole A.M. Collins